Righteously Releasing at Huarong 义释华容

📖 As recorded in the classical booksBook result: Draw心武残编

📚 Xinwu Canbian — a Ming-dynasty endgame manual

楚河漢界cotuong.synerworlds.com將兵士象車兵炮俥兵車傌俥砲卒帥仕卒仕cotuong.synerworlds.com

The two sides are almost perfectly matched: Red has two chariots, a knight, a cannon and three pawns; Black also has two chariots and a cannon, with advisors and elephants guarding the palace and two pawns. Neither side owns a finishing blow, neither will give ground — and the classical manual Tâm Võ Tàn Biên concludes exactly that: draw. It is pure deadlock, where everything turns on a single careless move. The name retells Guan Yu's interception at the Huarong path after Red Cliffs in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms — the most famous release of a captured foe in the novel — and a fictional one: the histories record no such scene. Why did Zhuge Liang, who foresaw it all, send precisely Guan Yu? The answer is in the anecdote below. On this board: if you had to pick one side to play for a win, which would you choose — and why?

📖 Anecdotes

華容道で関羽は刀を構えた――そして曹操を行かせた

赤壁の後、敗れた曹操は華容道を逃げました。その先で待ち伏せていたのは、彼を討つという軍令状に署名した関羽。ところが関羽は曹操に深い恩義を負っていました。刃は落ちるのでしょうか、それとも恩が勝つのでしょうか? 『三国志演義』(第50回)で、諸葛亮はまさにこうなると知って関羽を送り込みます。関羽はかつて曹操に手厚く遇されたことを思い出し、刃を下げ、旧恩の主を見逃し、自ら署名した軍令のもとで罰を受け入れます。義務と恩義の衝突として、小説で最も有名な場面です。 史実は違います。『三国志』が注釈で引く『山陽公載記』には待ち伏せも釈放も記録がありません。曹操は逃げ延び、劉備が火を放つのが遅すぎただけだ…

— Đội ngũ SynerWorlds

Stories around this position — storytelling, not part of the engine-verified content.

Source
心武残编
Book result
Draw
Verification
📖 As recorded in the classical books
Side to move
Red to move
Difficulty
Hard
Red forces
King, Advisor ×2, Horse, Chariot ×2, Cannon, Pawn ×3
Black forces
King, Advisor, Elephant, Chariot ×2, Cannon, Pawn ×2
FEN
3k5/P3a4/b2r2P1c/9/9/3R5/4P4/4r1NRC/1p1KAp3/3A5 w

Open this position in the app: try it against the computer or watch the engines play it out.

▶ Play this study

Load this position into the Setup editor: rearrange it, edit it and try your own variations.

🧩 Open in Setup